Van Gogh and His Struggles With Mental Health
Share
- Vincent van Gogh created over 2,100 artworks, including 860 oil paintings, during a short 10-year career (1880–1890). His vibrant, bold style transformed Post-Impressionism.
- His work was deeply tied to his mental health challenges, including depression, anxiety, psychosis, and potential conditions like bipolar disorder and epilepsy.
- Major episodes, including the Arles crisis (cutting off his ear) and his time at Saint-Rémy psychiatric hospital, influenced his art, such as The Starry Night.
- Painting and writing were therapeutic outlets for Van Gogh, helping him process emotions and maintain resilience.
- Modern mental health discussions and creative therapy programs draw inspiration from his life, emphasizing the connection between art and healing.
Van Gogh – Challenging the 'Tortured Genius' Myth
Mental Health Conditions
Vincent van Gogh's struggles with mental health are well-documented through his letters, medical records, and accounts from those who knew him. These details shed light on the episodes described below.
Main Symptoms
Van Gogh experienced severe symptoms such as mood swings, hallucinations, and confusion. He also dealt with digestive issues and insomnia. His brother Theo once remarked:
"It seems as if he were two persons: one, marvelously gifted, tender and refined, the other, egotistic and hard hearted."
Van Gogh himself admitted:
"I am a man of passion."
These symptoms often fueled the intensity of his creative work.
Medical Analysis
Over 30 different diagnoses have been suggested by experts. A 2020 study in the International Journal of Bipolar Disorders highlighted several likely conditions Van Gogh may have suffered from:
| Condition | Key Characteristics |
|---|---|
| Bipolar Mood Disorder | Alternating periods of intense creativity and deep depression |
| Borderline Personality Disorder | Impulsivity, fear of abandonment, unstable relationships |
| Alcohol Use Disorder | Heavy drinking, particularly absinthe and other spirits |
| Temporal Lobe Epilepsy | Seizures and episodes of confusion |
Dr. Théophile Peyron, who treated Van Gogh at Saint-Rémy, described his condition as involving "attacks of epilepsy, separated by long intervals". His symptoms were likely worsened by poor nutrition, heavy alcohol consumption, and smoking. These factors provide context for the challenges he faced during his artistic career.
Key Events and Episodes
Van Gogh's mental health struggles can be traced through several critical episodes:
-
Early Signs (1873–1878)
During these years, Van Gogh showed signs of melancholy, withdrew socially, and became deeply absorbed in religion. He wrote:
"My head is sometimes numb and is often burning hot, and my thoughts are confused."
-
The Arles Crisis (December 1888)
A major breakdown occurred after Paul Gauguin left their shared home in Arles. In distress, Van Gogh cut off part of his left ear. Dr. Félix Rey described this as "a transient over-excitement", while Dr. Jules Urpar referred to it as "an attack of acute mania with generalized delirium". -
Saint-Rémy Period (1889–1890)
At Saint-Rémy, Van Gogh endured four significant episodes. The most intense occurred between mid-July and late August 1889, during which he described himself as having a "disturbed mind" and feeling "absolutely distraught". Another prolonged episode from February to April 1890 left him "totally dazed" and unable to work.
Mental Health Effects on Painting
Changes in Technique
Van Gogh's artistic style shifted alongside his mental health. During his early, more depressive periods, he leaned towards somber earth tones. Later, as he interacted with Impressionist artists like Monet and Gauguin during more stable times, his work adopted the vibrant colors and dynamic brushwork we now associate with his name. These changes in technique reflect the emotional highs and lows that shaped his most famous pieces.
Key Paintings and Mental State
Van Gogh's paintings provide a window into his mental state during different periods of his life:
| Painting | Period | Mental State Reflection |
|---|---|---|
| The Potato Eaters | Early Period | Depressive phase: dark, muted tones |
| Still Life with a Plate of Onions | Post-Hospital | Recovery phase: personal items symbolizing renewal |
| Garden of the Asylum | Saint-Paul-de-Mausole | Treatment phase: nature as a source of solace |
| The Starry Night | During Crisis | Turbulent phase: intense, swirling patterns and colors |
Van Gogh's nocturnal works, like The Starry Night, illustrate the deep connection between his emotions and his art. He once wrote:
"This morning I saw the countryside from my window a long time before sunrise, with nothing but the morning star, which looked very big."
His art not only captured his struggles but also provided a sense of refuge and expression.
Painting as Therapy
During his stay at Saint-Paul-de-Mausole, painting became a vital outlet for Van Gogh. Over just 70 stable days, he created 75 paintings and more than 100 sketches of the surrounding landscapes.
The Van Gogh Museum explains:
"Painting was the best remedy for his psychiatric disorder, but he couldn't work during attacks and indeed wasn't allowed to. Doing nothing was unbearable for Vincent."
Nature played a dual role in Van Gogh's life - it inspired his art and helped him cope emotionally. Painting became his lifeline during some of his darkest moments.
sbb-itb-5558ffc
Personal Letters
Common Topics
Van Gogh's 820 letters to Theo provide a window into his personal struggles and artistic aspirations. These letters often explore recurring themes that reflect his mental health journey and creative process:
| Theme | Context | Impact on Mental Health |
|---|---|---|
| Artistic Purpose | Saw art as a form of salvation | His work became a source of emotional stability |
| Nature & Poetry | Found peace in the natural world | Nature provided comfort during difficult times |
| Inner Struggles | Dealt with depression and anxiety | Openly shared his battles, offering insight |
| Hospital Experiences | Observed fellow patients | Helped him normalize his condition |
These themes highlight how writing became a therapeutic outlet for Van Gogh, helping him process his emotions and find meaning in his struggles.
Writing for Mental Health
Van Gogh's letters were more than just correspondence - they were a lifeline during his darkest moments. Out of over 2,000 letters he wrote, 903 still exist, showcasing how writing helped him cope with trauma and maintain connections. While hospitalized, his letters - often accompanied by 240 sketches - provided a glimpse into his mental state and artistic ambitions.
His letters capture a raw mix of despair and determination. In one particularly vulnerable moment, he expressed:
"I am so angry with myself because I cannot do what I should like to do, and at such a moment one feels as if one were lying bound hand and foot at the bottom of a deep dark well, utterly helpless." - Vincent van Gogh
Yet, even in these moments, he found reasons to keep moving forward:
"How much sadness there is in life! Nevertheless one must not become melancholy. One must seek distraction in other things, and the right thing is to work." - Vincent van Gogh
Interestingly, about one-third of his letters were written in French. This allowed him to express emotions in ways that sometimes felt more natural than his native Dutch.
Van Gogh's empathy also shines through in his reflections on others facing similar challenges. He wrote:
"I observe in others that, like me, they too have heard sounds and strange voices during their crises, that things also appeared to change before their eyes. And that softens the horror that I retained at first of the crisis I had... Had I not seen other mad people at close hand I wouldn't have been able to rid myself of thinking about it all the time." - Vincent van Gogh
These letters not only document his struggles but also reveal his resilience and ability to find solace in creativity and connection.
Medical Care in the 1800s
1800s Mental Health Views
During the 1800s, mental health care began moving away from severe measures toward newer approaches. Early treatments often involved bleeding, ice water immersion, and physical restraints. By the 1820s, attitudes shifted, with mental illness increasingly seen as a condition that could be treated rather than as a moral failing or "unacceptable deviancy". Psychiatry during this time categorized mental illnesses into five main types:
| Category | Characteristics |
|---|---|
| Mania | Intense agitation and excitement |
| Melancholia | Deep depression |
| Monomania | Obsession with a single idea |
| Dementia | Cognitive decline |
| Idiocy | Developmental impairments |
These changing perspectives laid the groundwork for more personalized care, such as the treatment Vincent van Gogh received.
Hospital Stays
Van Gogh's year-long stay at Saint-Paul-de-Mausole psychiatric hospital, starting in May 1889, is an example of late 19th-century mental health care. This private hospital accommodated only 18 male patients. While there, Van Gogh followed a structured daily routine and even had access to a studio where he continued creating art .
Support Network
Van Gogh's treatment involved several key figures, including Dr. Félix Rey in Arles and Dr. Gachet in Auvers. A certificate from the time reflects the community's awareness of his struggles:
"Mr Vincent is suffering from insanity"
One of the era's major advancements was the moral treatment approach, led by Philippe Pinel. This method focused on social engagement, limiting physical restraints, and encouraging productive activities as therapeutic tools. These reforms shaped Van Gogh's care, highlighting a pivotal shift in how mental health was addressed during the 19th century.
Modern Impact
Mental Health Insights
Van Gogh's personal challenges have sparked a reevaluation of mental health in modern times, moving away from the outdated "mad genius" stereotype. For example, the Van Gogh Museum's "Open up with Vincent" program uses his story to foster conversations about mental well-being through activities like:
| Activity Type | Description | Schedule |
|---|---|---|
| Yoga Sessions | Collaborative classes with De Nieuwe Yogaschool, inspired by works like Almond Blossom | Monthly |
| Meditation Series | Online "Masterpiece Meditation" videos featuring Van Gogh's art | Always available online |
| Mindful Art Viewing | Guided sessions tied to the "Matthew Wong | Vincent van Gogh: Painting as a Last Resort" exhibition | March 22, May 3, June 7 |
These creative approaches not only celebrate his art but also encourage a more compassionate understanding of mental health.
Current Exhibitions
Modern art shows now reflect these updated perspectives on Van Gogh's life. For instance, the Tate Britain's "Van Gogh and Britain" exhibition challenges the "tortured genius" narrative, offering a more nuanced portrayal of his struggles and achievements. Studies even suggest that knowing about his personal battles, such as self-mutilation, can deepen viewers' appreciation of works like Sunflowers.
Why It Matters Today
Van Gogh's experiences remain a powerful touchpoint in discussions about mental health within creative industries.
"Until the end, Van Gogh painted in spite of his illness, not because of it. It's important to remember that." – Nienke Bakker, Curator at the Van Gogh Museum
His openness about hearing voices and experiencing altered perceptions has helped normalize conversations around mental health. Today, both mental health experts and art institutions use his story to highlight the value of accessible care and the healing power of creativity. The Van Gogh Museum continues to lead these efforts, using his legacy to inspire understanding and support.
Conclusion
Vincent van Gogh's life highlights the deep connection between mental health struggles and artistic expression. During his time at the Saint-Rémy-de-Provence mental hospital, he created around 150 paintings, showing incredible dedication even in the face of immense personal challenges.
His journey not only influenced the art world but also shaped how we think about art's role in mental health. Van Gogh himself described his art as "the lightning conductor for my illness", a sentiment that still resonates in discussions about creative expression and its therapeutic benefits.
Producing thousands of works while battling severe mental health issues, Van Gogh demonstrated an extraordinary commitment to his craft.
"I am seeking, I am striving, I am in it with all my heart." - Vincent van Gogh
His resilience and passion continue to inspire modern approaches to mental health treatment and creative therapy. For example, the National Alliance on Mental Illness honors his legacy through programs like the Iris Project, using the iris as a symbol of hope for mental health awareness.
Van Gogh's story is a powerful reminder that mental health struggles, while challenging, do not have to limit creativity or achievement. His life underscores how art can serve as both a form of expression and a path to healing, offering timeless lessons for understanding the role of creativity in mental health.